If you're about to sell, you might have been given the classic advice. Get three estate agents round to value your home, then pick the best one.
I've chosen estate agents well over 1,000 times, for my own sales and for my clients' sales. And I've learned that it's one of the fastest ways to lose money. It's also how people get stuck with a sale that drags on for months.
So how should you choose an estate agent?
The best way to choose an estate agent is on evidence, not on the valuation visit. Shortlist the agents selling the most homes like yours nearby right now, favour those with the most similar, recent sales, then interview them. Choosing on trust, likeability, the highest valuation, the lowest fee or a tip usually backfires.
But there's more to it than that. Once you see what a valuation visit really is, every one of the usual mistakes starts to make sense...
If you'd rather cut to the chase, I've designed a short quiz. It works out the best way to sell your home, given your property and your priorities. It takes about 60 seconds and you get your results straight away.
Hit the button below to get started:
First, the one thing that explains why the standard advice goes wrong.
Why an estate agent's valuation visit is really a sales pitch
When an estate agent comes round to value your home, they aren't there to give you a valuation. They're there to win your business. Getting you signed up is literally their job. So the agent who impresses you most in that meeting is often just the best salesperson, not the best agent for your sale.
That's the key thing to understand. Every agent who walks through your door wants one thing from that hour: your signature on their contract.
So if we choose our agent based on how that meeting goes, we end up with whoever gave the best sales pitch. And that's where things start to go wrong.
Let me show you what I mean. There are six ways most people choose their estate agent. I've been tempted by a few of them myself over the years, and every one of them can backfire.
1. Should you pick the estate agent you trust the most?
Choosing the estate agent who seems most trustworthy is unreliable, because building trust quickly is a core sales skill. Any decent salesperson can make you feel comfortable in an hour. It tells you they're good at winning instructions. It doesn't tell you their company will do the best job of selling your home.
It sounds sensible. The problem is, it's literally a salesperson's job to make us trust them.
In an hour-long valuation appointment, any decent salesperson can make you feel comfortable and in safe hands. That doesn't mean their company is the best one for selling your home. It just means they're good at winning new instructions.
So be really careful about leaning on who feels trustworthy. That feeling is exactly what the meeting is designed to produce.
Right, so trust aside. What about picking the agent you simply get on with best?
2. Should you pick the estate agent you like the most?
Liking an estate agent is not a good reason to hire them. You're not looking for someone to invite to a family barbecue. You need someone to sell a house and do a really good job of it. Having dealt with hundreds of estate agents over the years, I can tell you the two don't necessarily overlap.
I hear this one all the time. "I went with that agent because the chap who came out was lovely." And I have to remind myself of this too. It's a very human way to decide.
But we're not choosing someone to go for drinks with after work on a Friday. We just need them to sell the house, and sell it well.
Some of the most likeable agents I've ever come across have been horribly useless. And some of the most effective ones, I wouldn't want to spend an evening with. So if you lean too heavily on who you like, it's easy to pick the wrong one.
So what about the agent who seems to believe in your home the most, and puts the biggest number on it?
3. Should you pick the estate agent with the highest valuation?
Choosing the estate agent with the highest valuation is the most costly way to pick one. Agents know the highest figure often wins the instruction, so some deliberately pitch high to get you signed up. There's no penalty for them if your home doesn't sell at that price. The cost of overpricing falls entirely on you.
Of all six, this is the one I'd beg you not to do. It feels logical. The agent with the highest valuation seems the most confident. They clearly believe in your home and in their own ability. So why would you go with the bloke who said he'd sell it for £10,000 less?
Well, think about what happens if they can't sell it for that price. They don't get fined. They don't have to make up the difference out of their wages. There's no consequence for them at all, and that's exactly why so many of them do it.
For us as sellers, though, overpricing has very real consequences:
- Your home sits on the market for longer.
The buyers who are out there right now compare you with everything else at that price, and they move on. - You get less interest.
Fewer viewings, fewer offers, and less competition between the buyers you do get. - You often end up reducing the price anyway.
Only now your listing has been sitting there for weeks, and buyers can see it. - You may sell for less in the end.
A reduced, stale listing tends to attract lower offers than a fresh one priced right from day one.
And this isn't just my opinion. In July 2026, Rightmove reported that homes priced right from day one found a buyer in around 36 days on average. Homes that later needed a price reduction took 127 days. That's roughly 3.5 times longer.
Fair warning: When we surveyed home sellers about their estate agents, shady valuation tactics were one of the three most common complaints. If one valuation comes in well above the others, ask that agent to show you the recent sold prices that justify it.
So if the biggest valuation is a trap, surely the smallest fee is the safe bet? Not quite...
4. Should you pick the cheapest estate agent?
Choosing the cheapest estate agent rarely saves you money. The gap between the cheapest and the most expensive agent is usually around 1% of your home's value or less. An experienced, proactive agent will often make you more than that back, through better buyers, stronger negotiation and fewer things going wrong.
This one feels logical as well. The less we spend on fees, surely the more we keep at the end?
The problem is that the fee is a tiny sliver of the sale price. Even the difference between the cheapest and the most expensive estate agent in your area might be 1% of your home's value.
Now picture the two agents you could end up with:
- The cheap, inexperienced, inattentive one.
They don't follow up buyers, they drop the ball, and they're weak at negotiating. - The experienced, driven one.
They hit the phones, chase progress, push for more money and stay engaged with your sale from start to finish.
Do you think the second agent can make up 1% or more? From my experience, the answer is a huge, resounding yes.
The best estate agents will make you more money than they cost you. It's a lesson I've learned over and over.
So don't be sucked in by the lowest quote. There's a good chance you'll end up worse off in the long run.
Want to know what you're actually paying for, and how to negotiate it? I've covered that in my guide to estate agent fees and the 9 things I wish I'd known.
Okay. If you can't trust the pitch, surely you can trust your mates? Let's look at recommendations...
5. Should you use the estate agent your friends recommend?
A friend's recommendation is a well-meaning but unreliable way to choose an estate agent. Their sale is one sample from the hundreds that agent handles each year. The agent may suit a different type of home. The person who did the work may have moved on. And luck plays a bigger part in any one sale than most people realise.
Normally this is the best recommendation we can get. If your best mate is a real foodie and tells you about a restaurant you have to try, that carries a lot of weight. Friends and family know you and have your best interests at heart. It should be perfect.
But it turns out this is a poor way to pick an estate agent. There are three reasons why:
- Estate agents aren't one size fits all.
Different agents suit different types of property, different price brackets and different pockets of your area. Your friend may have found the perfect agent for their home. That doesn't mean they're right for yours. - Estate agents change over time.
An agency isn't really a company in the way we imagine. It's a group of individuals doing the work. Say the person who did so well for your friend has left, or been promoted, or just isn't working on your sale. Your experience will be completely different. - There's a big element of luck in any sale.
The agent who sold your friend's house might have done everything wrong and got lucky. The right buyer stumbled across the listing on Rightmove, offered a good price, and pushed it through with their own solicitor. The agent might have had nothing to do with it.
That luck cuts both ways. I've seen plenty of good agents do all the right things and still have a sale go wrong. The homeowner walks away thinking they were useless, and that's the story you'd hear.
You can't remove luck from a house sale, but you can stack the odds in your favour. Nearly everything I write is about taking control of your sale so that you do.
Recommendations are well-intentioned. Just take them with a very careful pinch of salt.
So if one person's experience isn't enough to go on, what about hundreds of them? That's where online reviews come in...
6. Should you pick the estate agent with the best reviews?
Online reviews can only play a small part in choosing an estate agent. The main problem isn't fake reviews. It's that some agents campaign hard for reviews and others never ask. So a small agent doing average work can look far better online than a busy agent doing excellent work.
If you're like most people, you check the reviews before any big decision. It's another useful source of feedback. But there are big problems to be aware of here, and not the ones you might expect.
Most people assume the issue is fake reviews. To be honest, I haven't seen much fake review peddling among estate agents. You definitely see it with "we buy any house" companies, where it's a real problem. I've written separately about whether you can trust house-buying company reviews.
With estate agents, the issue is different:
- Some agents never ask for reviews.
I know agents selling tons of homes and doing really good work who make no effort to ask sellers for a review afterwards. So they barely have any. - Some agents campaign for them.
I've seen agents doing far lower volumes, often with pretty poor work, who really push for a review every time something goes well.
The result is that the second agent's reviews end up looking far better than the first's, even though they're smaller and worse. That's why reviews can only ever play a small part in your decision.
So here's where that leaves us. The six usual ways of choosing all measure the wrong thing:
| How most people choose | What it actually tells you |
|---|---|
|
The agent you trust most |
How good they are at building trust in an hour |
|
The agent you like most |
Whether you'd enjoy a drink with them |
|
The highest valuation |
How badly they want your instruction |
|
The lowest fee |
How cheaply they're prepared to work, not how well |
|
A friend's recommendation |
One sale out of hundreds, with luck mixed in |
|
The best reviews |
How hard they push happy sellers to leave one |
None of those tell you the thing you actually need to know: who is best at selling homes like yours, right now. So what should you do instead?
How to choose an estate agent: my 3-step process
To choose an estate agent well, build a shortlist on evidence rather than opinions. Prioritise the agents who have sold very similar homes very nearby, very recently. Then interview them against specific checks. Done this way, you reliably end up with the best local agent for your home and price bracket right now.
Over the years I've been through this process and selected well over 1,000 estate agents, for my own sales and for my clients' sales. Over time it's turned into a simple three-step process that just works, time and time again.
- Step 1: Build a shortlist on evidence.
Not opinions, not recommendations, but actual performance. You want a shortlist of agents who are selling lots of homes similar to yours, nearby, at the moment. - Step 2: Refine the list.
Prioritise the agents who've sold something very similar, very nearby, very recently. A flat in the same block. A house in the same row of terraces. There are a couple of reasons this pays dividends. The obvious one is that they already know what those homes achieved and who was looking. - Step 3: Interview them for the job.
Then speak with them. You're not checking "do I like this person?" or "was that a good pitch?" or "what do the reviews say?". There are three specific things I'm checking for when I talk to them, and none of them are about the pitch.
When I follow this process, we end up with the best agent for the job, reliably. It flips the whole thing on its head. You're no longer waiting to be won over. You're the one doing the choosing.
Prefer to watch? This guide comes from my video How Most People Choose Estate Agents (And Why It Backfires).
And if you'd rather my team and I just handled the whole sale for you, that's exactly what we do. You can read about our accelerated sale service and apply online to see if we can help.
One last thing before you go and build that shortlist.
Is choosing an estate agent this way right for you?
Choosing an estate agent on evidence suits almost anyone selling through an agent, whatever the price bracket. The one question it doesn't answer is whether an estate agent is the right route for you at all. For most sellers it is. If speed or certainty matter far more to you than price, other methods are worth a look.
For the vast majority of homeowners, a good estate agent is still the best way to sell. The process above is how you find that agent rather than the best salesperson.
But if you need a very fast or very certain sale, there are other routes, and each has its own trade-offs. I've compared them in my guide to the best way to sell a house.
Not sure which camp you're in? I've designed a free 60-second quiz to help. It works out the best way to sell your home, given your property and your priorities, and you get free, personalised advice straight away.
Thanks for reading, and hit the button below to get started:
Choosing an estate agent: your questions answered
A few more of the questions sellers ask me about how to choose an estate agent:
How many estate agents should you get round to value your house?
Getting two or three estate agents round is a reasonable starting point, as long as you don't choose between them on how the meeting feels. Pick who to invite on evidence: the agents selling the most homes like yours nearby right now. Then treat each visit as an interview you're running, not a pitch.
Should I choose the estate agent with the highest valuation?
Choosing the estate agent with the highest valuation is the most expensive mistake a seller can make. Some agents pitch high purely to win the instruction, and there's no penalty for them if the price is wrong. Rightmove's data shows homes that later need a reduction take around 127 days to find a buyer. Homes priced right first time take around 36.
Is the cheapest estate agent a false economy?
The cheapest estate agent is usually a false economy. The gap between the cheapest and dearest agent is often around 1% of your home's value. A proactive, experienced agent can easily add more than that through stronger negotiation and better follow-up. Judge agents on their recent results with homes like yours first, then negotiate the fee.
Can you trust estate agent reviews?
Estate agent reviews are worth a glance but should only play a small part in your decision. Fake reviews are less of a problem with estate agents than with house-buying companies. The bigger issue is that some agents campaign for reviews and others never ask. So review counts reflect how hard an agent pushes for feedback, not how well they sell.
Should I use the estate agent my friend recommended?
A friend's recommendation is one sale out of the hundreds an estate agent handles, so treat it with care. The agent may specialise in a different type of home or price bracket. The person who impressed your friend may have moved on. And luck plays a big part in any single sale. Check the agent against recent sales of homes like yours before you decide.
What is the best way to choose an estate agent?
The best way to choose an estate agent is a three-step process based on evidence. Shortlist the agents selling lots of homes like yours nearby right now. Prioritise those with very similar, very recent sales. Then interview them against specific checks, not on likeability or the size of their valuation. This reliably finds the best local agent for your home and price bracket.
By Matthew Cooper, Co-Founder of Home Selling Expert






